So … It Appears that September Will Be all About the MCM

News about the death of the MCM / MCSM broke right around the time I was starting to write up an interesting case study involving the ascending key problem (for those unfamiliar, see Gail Shaw’s excellent writeup for example), so that post will probably need to wait for a while. It’s not my intent to rehash the #SQLMCM issue here, if anyone who cares about the MCM (Microsoft Certified Master) program isn’t already up to speed on the basic issues a good starting point can be found from Jason Brimhall and at the #SQLMCM hash tag on twitter. Part of the reason that I am not really ranting is that I am actually relatively fortunate. I had been planning to take the lab exam (final hurdle before becoming a MCM) at the end of September anyway so the only real impacts on me are

  • I need to decide whether or not it’s worth following through with the exam when the certification is dying (the answer is probably yes).
  • I am sure I will need to cover this out of my pocket now. I’ve been fortunate enough to have a part-time W-2 gig (on top of my consulting load) that has actually been quite supportive of my MCM quest up to this point. Now that “the email” has gone out I am frankly too embarrassed to even ask if they would care to pony up a couple of grand more for the final test when the plug is getting pulled the day after (maybe literally) I take the exam. Maybe the only reason to consider doing so is that I actually wrote the MCM attempt into my performance plan for the year. This is actually not as bad as it sounds, I am dual employed so it really is only fair that Rick-the-consultant pays part of the certification expense which will benefit me equally in both of my current roles.
  • Some lost prep time. When I said I planned to take the exam at the end of September that was my optimistic estimate. In the back of my head I had actually started telling myself I may wait until the end of October. That exam is no joke, an extra month of prep time would have been handy.
  • It’s all riding on this attempt. Before the announcement I figured that if I did not pass this attempt I could consider regrouping for another try before the MCM exams were retired in favor of the new MCSM exams.

First : MCM vs MCSM – A Long Tangent

But I’m not interested in dwelling because I really am one of the lucky ones. I’m more interested in offering my perspective as one who is in the pipeline at this point in history. First and foremost I was always a lot more excited about the legacy MCM certification than I was about the MCSM. I just felt “Microsoft Certified Master” was an awesome description. It is intuitive. It rolls off the tongue. It is clear. I imagine my future self shaking hands slightly more firmly and standing slightly straighter as “Rick Lowe, Microsoft Certified Master”. It is immediately clear to any person who hears this exactly what I am claiming (that I am awesome), why I feel justified in claiming it (my awesomeness has been certified), and what evidence is available (this Rick guy should be able to cough up a transcript sharing code). This is actually why I am ready to take the exam, if I had not been concerned with becoming a MCM I probably would have been hanging back, updating my credentials from MCITP to MCSE and waiting from the MCSM exams to be published.

On the other hand, when I imagine a possible future self introducing himself as “Rick Lowe, MCSM”, or worse “Rick Lowe, Microsoft Certified Solution Master on the Data Platform” I am pretty sure I will be slouching as the eyes of whoever I’m speaking to glaze over slightly. “That is not just more alphabet soup”, my future self says, “that is a pinnacle certification. Here, let me draw you a diagram of all the new SQL Server certifications so you can see this blue pyramid thingie. Look, there’s no gray at all in this pyramid which means this is the good one. You should really be rather impressed with me about now”. I suppose the alphabet soup issue is what really bothered my about the change from MCM to MCSM. Aside from just being a cool title MCM, both when spoken and written, looks quite different from MCITP which could be important when speaking with somebody outside of the SQL Server community. Even if they may have seen hundreds of resumes for “paper” MCITPs it is possible that the fact MCM sounds different may be enough to get their attention. MCSM, on the other hand, visually and verbally kind of blends in with MCSA and MCSE.

If it seems like I’m taking cheap shots at a particular set of visual aids that is not my intent. I love visual aids and have nothing against blue and grey pyramids. If I haven’t been clear enough, the point I am really trying to make is that the visual aids are not just helpful for understanding the certification roadmap, they may actually be kind of necessary for understanding the current roadmap unless one has a very good head for acronyms. And this does not help when it comes to acceptance of the current generation of credentials by business leaders.

But more importantly, Can we chart our own destiny?

Plenty has been written on the tricky revenue problem posed by the MCM exams (rather steep fixed costs would need to be offset by a relative handful of test takers before this test is profitable). One commonly expressed concern is that it may just be too difficult for Microsoft to make a profit from the MCM/MCSM program and may simply never reintroduce the concept of a pinnacle certification. Another is that they may fix the revenue issue by dumbing down the tests enough to increase the percentage of SQL Server MCPs who would be able to pass. More potential conversions would probably mean more test takers which would definitely mean more revenue. Both of these cases are troublesome for many in the community who value the rigor and the “unfakeability” of the MCM/MCSM exams.

My question at this point is this : if we as a community do not have a lot of faith that Microsoft will bring back the MCM in a satisfactory form, or if we are concerned that we just care more about this particular certification than they do, why are we waiting for them to do so?

It’s probably not realistic for anyone to expect the creation of a “Community Certified Master of SQL Server” program. Don’t get me wrong, it would be fantastic if somebody could come to a conference, sign up for a “test your mettle” hands-on precon or postcon, and potentially walk out as a “CCM”. But getting the community involved in the master testing process does not change the underlying economic issues. Developing the test would take a tremendous amount of effort. Administering the test would be a nightmare. Do we offer the test online? Probably not because it would be too easy for somebody to either cheat or capture the questions to look up later. Establish a dedicated testing center? Probably not realistic for this volume of test takers. Remote proctor? Maybe, but that could be very expensive because it probably requires something close to a 1:1 ratio of proctors to test takers. Co-locate with a conference? Might be the most workable but is it a problem if the exam can only be attempted once or twice a year?

And of course, even if a delivery method is found this does not change the underlying issues. Developing a MCM-type test would be very expensive (it bears repeating). Convincing industry that it should care about the CCM would be even more difficult than it was to try to convince them to care about the MCM. I am sure there are many many more.

Unfortunately I actually do not have any productive suggestions here, all I can really do at this point is suggest that the death of the MCM could be an opportunity for us to do something even better. And it may be foolish to believe this means testing – as Brent Ozar points out there are a lot of cool experiments we could conduct that have nothing to do with a traditional certification program. But if anyone does have an idea I may be interested in pitching in. After October 1, of course. The rest of September is cut out for me.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s